# E1 - I Had a Feeling We Could All Become Magical Girls Together
Source: [Crunchyroll](https://www.crunchyroll.com/watch/GEVUZ822D/i-had-a-feeling-we-could-all-become-magical-girls-together)
Translator:
Editor:
Timer:
QC:
(Please feel free to edit the speaker names if incomplete or inaccurate. Names are handled on a best-effort basis depending on the info on the source file. Dialogue is left as is.)
**[00:24] ---**
Homura, leave it to me!
**[00:26] ---**
Wait, Kaname! I'll go, too!
**[00:58] ---**
Come to Kamihama City.
**[01:01] ---**
Come to Kamihama City.
In this town, Magical Girls are saved.
**[01:06] ---**
Wh-Who's there?
**[01:08] ---**
Come to Kamihama City.
In this town, Magical Girls are saved.
**[01:13] ---**
Come to Kamihama City.
In this town, Magical Girls are saved.
**[01:17] ---**
Come to Kamihama City.
**[01:19] ---**
Kamihama? Saved?
**[01:22] ---**
What...
**[01:31] ---**
No!
**[01:32] ---**
Madoka!
**[01:47] ---**
Thank you, Sayaka.
**[01:49] ---**
You came back!
**[01:51] ---**
You saved us, Miki.
**[01:59] ---**
Are you trying to get Madoka killed?
**[02:02] ---**
If you can't actually fight,
then just stay out of this!
**[02:07] ---**
I'm sorry...
**[02:08] ---**
Stop it, Sayaka! It's not Homura's fault!
**[02:12] ---**
I ran ahead on my own...
**[02:17] ---**
Anyway, how did it go? Did you find Mami?
**[02:23] ---**
I did find Mami.
**[02:26] ---**
Great!
**[02:27] ---**
I found her, but...
**[02:32] ---**
She's not the Mami we know anymore.
**[02:42] ---**
What do we do?
**[02:44] ---**
Sayaka?
**[02:47] ---**
What do we do?
**[02:49] ---**
We're going to turn into Witches!
**[02:57] ---**
The price of a wish made in hope is a Soul Gem.
**[03:02] ---**
These jewels are the soul of a magical girl.
**[03:07] ---**
This little rock is who I am.
**[03:10] ---**
When it's filled with despair
and becomes completely clouded,
**[03:15] ---**
a Magical Girl becomes a Witch,
one that curses this world and endlessly takes lives.
**[03:27] ---**
The price of a Magical Girl attaining their hope
is that they must accept this curse,
**[03:32] ---**
and continue to fight without end.
**[03:35] ---**
Until they die in battle against a Witch,
or become a Witch themselves.
**[03:42] ---**
That is the fate of a Magical Girl.
**[03:50] ---**
If a Magical Girl goes to Kamihama City,
she can be saved.
**[03:54] ---**
In Kamihama City,
a Magical Girl can be freed from her fate.
**[04:00] ---**
I didn't understand the meaning of those rumors
until I learned the truth about Magical Girls.
**[04:14] ---**
No... You're lying!
**[04:17] ---**
I don't want to believe it either.
**[04:19] ---**
That Witches are actually what Magical Girls become.
**[04:25] ---**
Then, Kyubey lied to us?
**[04:30] ---**
Lied? That's a rather rude way to put it.
**[04:33] ---**
Kyubey...
**[04:34] ---**
You were granted a wish that you could've spent
your whole lives trying and failing to fulfill,
**[04:39] ---**
and paid the price of becoming a Magical Girl to do it.
**[04:43] ---**
It's a fair trade.
**[04:45] ---**
But you didn't say we'd become Witches!
**[04:48] ---**
Well, you didn't ask.
**[04:50] ---**
You can't expect us to accept that!
**[04:52] ---**
If you don't want to become Witches,
defeat them and take their Grief Seeds.
**[04:58] ---**
If you can keep purifying
your Soul Gems with Grief Seeds,
**[05:01] ---**
you can theoretically live forever.
**[05:05] ---**
Considering your lifespan and capabilities
compared to a normal human, it's not a bad trade.
**[05:10] ---**
Defeat Witches?
**[05:12] ---**
They were originally Magical Girls, just like us, right?
**[05:16] ---**
That's right.
Human girls who made a contract with me.
**[05:20] ---**
But the only way to free them
from the fate that binds them is to defeat them.
**[05:28] ---**
Why would you do something so terrible?
**[05:30] ---**
In the moment when your Soul Gems burn out
and become Grief Seeds,
**[05:36] ---**
they create incredible energy.
**[05:39] ---**
As Incubators, it is our job to recover that energy.
**[05:44] ---**
Just for that?
**[05:47] ---**
Eventually, the entropy in the universe will expand
until it dies from heat death.
**[05:53] ---**
To extend its lifespan, it needs energy not bound
by the laws of thermodynamics. It's very important!
**[06:01] ---**
Don't you think—
**[06:03] ---**
Of course not!
**[06:05] ---**
Sayaka?
**[06:06] ---**
Because of you, myself and Mami...
and Madoka!
**[06:13] ---**
That was mean.
**[06:15] ---**
I'm trying to have a peaceful conversation.
**[06:17] ---**
Kyubey...
**[06:18] ---**
How?
**[06:20] ---**
For some reason, when humans regret their decisions
due to misunderstanding the situation,
**[06:25] ---**
you come to hate others.
**[06:28] ---**
I just don't get it.
**[06:30] ---**
Die!
**[06:41] ---**
Kaname...
**[06:46] ---**
You're pretty calm,
considering what you just heard.
**[06:50] ---**
Did you know this?
**[06:52] ---**
Sayaka!
**[06:53] ---**
Calm down, please.
**[06:55] ---**
Why didn't you tell us?
**[06:56] ---**
Did you know,
and just laugh at us the whole time?
**[06:59] ---**
That's not true.
**[07:00] ---**
Wait, Sayaka!
**[07:02] ---**
This isn't the time to be fighting each other!
**[07:04] ---**
Kaname!
**[07:06] ---**
Yes, being a Magical Girl is tough,
but we can't leave that Witch alone.
**[07:11] ---**
And we need to save Mami!
**[07:15] ---**
Save her?
**[07:16] ---**
She wasn't normal, right?
**[07:19] ---**
That's true, but...
**[07:23] ---**
*We'll all become Witches that scatter despair!*
**[07:29] ---**
*Everyone will be saved.*
**[07:31] ---**
*We have that right.*
**[07:33] ---**
*I swear I'll be the one to accomplish that!*
**[07:39] ---**
I don't understand...
**[07:42] ---**
If Mami is really trying to save Magical Girls...
**[07:48] ---**
Then why would she do something mean to you?
**[07:52] ---**
Because...
**[07:54] ---**
She must be being controlled by someone.
Maybe a Witch!
**[07:57] ---**
I know that! I know, but...
**[08:03] ---**
Is there anything we can do?
**[08:06] ---**
We can't even beat the Witches of Mitakihara right now!
**[08:11] ---**
And the Walpurisnacht is coming to Mitakihara soon.
**[08:17] ---**
The greatest, most evil Witch
that circles around the Earth...
**[08:21] ---**
No way we can defeat something like that!
**[08:26] ---**
I can't be like Mami.
**[08:40] ---**
I'm sorry.
I wasn't trying to lie to you.
**[08:44] ---**
Yeah, I know.
**[08:47] ---**
You were trying to keep us from falling to despair,
so you didn’t say anything, right?
**[08:53] ---**
Thank you.
**[08:55] ---**
Kaname...
**[08:58] ---**
But I'm okay.
**[09:00] ---**
It'll all be fine.
**[09:24] ---**
*I've repeated this time
over countless iterations to save Kaname.*
**[09:31] ---**
*Again and again, searching for an answer.*
**[09:46] ---**
*But this time, something new happened.*
**[09:52] ---**
*Maybe in this timeline...*
**[10:00] ---**
*This time, for sure...*
**[10:09] ---**
Listen carefully!
**[10:10] ---**
Calling a woman "Ms." has the advantage of
not specifying a woman's marital state, like "Miss" or "Mrs.",
**[10:16] ---**
but aggressive use of the word "Miss" to
signify your unmarried status
**[10:18] ---**
*Sayaka...
And Homura, too...*
**[10:22] ---**
may one day help with attaining
the coveted status of "Mrs."...
**[10:25] ---**
*I'm not someone you want to imitate.*
**[10:28] ---**
*I'm just faking it. No matter how scared I am
or how much it hurts, I can't open up to anybody.*
**[10:36] ---**
*All I do is cry by myself.*
**[10:38] ---**
*Being a Magical Girl isn't a good thing.*
**[10:45] ---**
*Mami, we're all going to come apart at this rate.*
**[10:55] ---**
*Kamihama City...*
**[10:56] ---**
*If I can find out what happened there,
I might find a hint to save Kaname.*
**[11:07] ---**
*This power...
It's the same Witch from yesterday!*
**[11:15] ---**
*The Witch's Kiss.*
**[11:18] ---**
*If she lures them into that barrier,
they'll be done for!*
**[11:48] ---**
*Now they'll be okay, for a while.*
**[12:07] ---**
*In this situation, Tomoe would...*
**[12:20] ---**
This feeling... It's Homura!
**[12:24] ---**
*Sayaka, can you hear me?*
**[12:26] ---**
*Homura's fighting the Witch from yesterday!*
**[12:30] ---**
*Huh? Why would she do that on her own?*
**[12:33] ---**
*Where are you now, Sayaka?*
**[12:36] ---**
Why?
**[12:39] ---**
*“Why?”*
**[12:41] ---**
*Are you telling me to come, too?*
**[12:44] ---**
*How can you keep caring about others
and not yourself?*
**[12:48] ---**
*I can't be like that.*
**[12:50] ---**
*I'm not strong like Mami!*
**[12:53] ---**
*That's why I'm scared!*
**[12:55] ---**
I am scared.
**[12:58] ---**
*I'm scared!
And I know Mami was, too!*
**[13:03] ---**
*Ever since then, I've been thinking...*
**[13:07] ---**
*And it felt like, if we were together,
we could be Magical Girls!*
**[13:10] ---**
*We could survive and live our lives
as Magical Girls!*
**[13:15] ---**
*Madoka...*
**[13:16] ---**
*Even if it was scary, or painful,
or too much to bear,*
**[13:19] ---**
*we can all talk and cry together.*
**[13:21] ---**
*Mami, and us too...*
**[13:25] ---**
We should never have become Magical Girls,
**[13:28] ---**
but as long as we were together,
I wouldn't have any regrets!
**[13:47] ---**
Please, Sayaka! Help me!
**[13:49] ---**
I can't, Madoka.
I'm not strong enough.
**[13:52] ---**
*I promise to save Homura!*
**[13:56] ---**
*So Sayaka, you save me!*
**[13:59] ---**
*And then someday, Homura will save you, too!*
**[14:04] ---**
*What are you talking about?
Why would I...*
**[14:07] ---**
*Because if you don't save me,
I won't be coming back!*
**[14:12] ---**
*Madoka? Wait, Madoka!*
**[14:18] ---**
I don't understand.
**[14:20] ---**
What do I do?
**[14:24] ---**
Save me, Mami.
**[14:31] ---**
I'm sorry, Kaname!
**[14:33] ---**
All I do is slow you down!
**[14:36] ---**
That's not true.
Thanks to you, nobody has died yet!
**[14:42] ---**
Kaname...
**[14:43] ---**
But no going off on your own again anymore.
**[14:48] ---**
Mami said the witches in Kamihama City
are stronger than the others.
**[14:53] ---**
So I can't...
**[14:56] ---**
...lose to a witch of Mitakihara!
**[15:10] ---**
*You used to be a Magical Girl like me, Miss Witch.*
**[15:17] ---**
*I'm sorry!*
**[15:43] ---**
Kaname!
**[15:50] ---**
Sayaka! You came!
**[15:55] ---**
Madoka, you can be really unfair sometimes.
**[15:59] ---**
If you say you won't be coming back,
then I have no choice but to save you, right?
**[16:05] ---**
If I'm a Magical Girl now,
then I can't spend all my time being depressed!
**[16:09] ---**
I need to be as strong as the rest of you!
**[16:36] ---**
Crap!
**[16:37] ---**
Miki!
**[16:41] ---**
That was dangerous!
What are you doing?
**[16:44] ---**
Sorry, I just came as fast as I could.
**[16:48] ---**
Hey, doesn't your magic...
**[16:51] ---**
That's right. If I touch you anywhere,
you can move with me even if time is stopped.
**[17:00] ---**
And maybe I shouldn't be worrying about you, but...
**[17:03] ---**
Oh, thanks.
**[17:10] ---**
I see...
**[17:13] ---**
Why didn't I realize something so simple.
**[17:18] ---**
I'm not the only one.
We're all Magical Girls, right?
**[17:33] ---**
Thank you, Madoka!
**[17:38] ---**
Let's fight! All of us, together!
**[17:43] ---**
Yeah!
**[17:45] ---**
Yes.
**[17:46] ---**
Okay, let's go!
No matter what, don't let go!
**[17:57] ---**
*Actually, I remember what she said.*
**[18:02] ---**
*You idiot.*
**[18:03] ---**
*We're Magical Girls!*
**[18:06] ---**
*There's nobody else like us!*
**[18:09] ---**
*I knew it from the start, but...*
**[18:13] ---**
Madoka!
**[18:14] ---**
Right!
**[18:25] ---**
Here we go!
**[18:31] ---**
Miki!
**[18:35] ---**
Sayaka!
**[18:40] ---**
Take this!
**[19:01] ---**
Here. Thanks for your help.
**[19:04] ---**
Thank you.
**[19:08] ---**
Sayaka...
**[19:10] ---**
We didn't lose!
**[19:12] ---**
We beat the Witch!
**[19:15] ---**
Just barely, though.
**[19:18] ---**
The Witches of Kamihama
are way stronger than this.
**[19:22] ---**
But we haven't lost yet!
**[19:25] ---**
Madoka...
**[19:26] ---**
Nothing's really begun for us.
**[19:30] ---**
Nothing has happened yet
to make us give up.
**[19:34] ---**
Kaname?
**[19:37] ---**
Well, I'm sure if it was just me,
I wouldn't have decided to be a Magical Girl.
**[19:43] ---**
But because of Mami, I was able to,
and I was able to save everyone else.
**[19:50] ---**
So now...
**[19:52] ---**
Now it's our turn to save Mami!
**[19:57] ---**
Yeah!
**[20:00] ---**
*It's going better than it ever has.*
**[20:05] ---**
*Maybe in this timeline, I really will...*
**[20:11] ---**
*I will save Kaname!*
**[20:21] ---**
[1] I Had a Feeling We Could
All Become Magical Girls Together
**[21:59] ---**
Where's Magius HQ?
**[22:01] ---**
I-I don't know...
**[22:08] ---**
Where's Magius HQ?
**[22:10] ---**
I said I don't know...
**[22:20] ---**
Where's Magius HQ?
**[22:23] ---**
It's true!
**[22:24] ---**
The rumor says it moves!
**[22:31] ---**
What's this rumor about?
**[22:35] ---**
Hotel Faint Hope.
**[22:38] ---**
There's no sense in searching for it.
**[22:41] ---**
Unless they come for you, you can't get inside.
**[22:48] ---**
Pardon me.
**[22:59] ---**
So you're, um...
**[23:10] ---**
Kuroe.
**[23:12] ---**
Oh, that's right.
**[23:16] ---**
Have you gotten used to your life
at Hotel Faint Hope?
**[23:20] ---**
Do you need something from me?
**[23:24] ---**
Do you know Sister... no, Tamaki Iroha?